We left you with a bet: of your €60 of groceries paid by card, how much leaks away in fees? In this episode: the answer, and why Brussels had to step in.
Every card payment moves a fee between the two banks: interchange. It is paid by the acquirer (the merchant's bank) to the issuer (the customer's bank).
In practice, at settlement, the issuer pays out the €60 minus interchange, the fee is withheld at source, transaction by transaction.
Settlement arrives already net: the issuer keeps interchange at source, on every transaction.
Your €60 of groceries, paid with a standard French debit card. Set the slider to the interchange the acquirer will pay the issuer, then release: the answer appears.
The issuer provides the payment guarantee for the merchant and protection for the cardholder. An authorised transaction = a paid merchant, even if the customer's account is overdrawn or the card was stolen. The issuer must also protect its customer, run the anti-fraud systems, and fund the cash advance of deferred debit and credit.
That guarantee scales with the transaction amount: the higher it is, the higher the risk. That's why interchange is a percentage, not a flat fee.
Interchange pays for these costs, and gives banks a reason to issue cards. Because a payment system is a two-sided market: it needs customers carrying a card and merchants accepting it. Interchange is the cursor that balances the two.
A scheme that raises its interchange attracts issuers, which issue more of its cards. Competition worked in reverse: it pushed up prices that merchants cannot negotiate. At France's scale, more than €600 billion is paid by card every year: a 0.1% shift means more than half a billion euros a year.
2015: the EU Interchange Fee Regulation (IFR) caps interchange on consumer cards across the EEA: 0.2% debit, 0.3% credit, your €0.12 from earlier. In France, the competition authority had led the way on CB fees back in 2011.
| The transaction | Interchange |
|---|---|
| EEA card at an EEA merchantsame country or not: a Spanish card in Paris | 0.2% / 0.3%IFR cap |
| Consumer card issued outside the EEA“inter-regional”: UK, US, China… | 1.15% / 1.5%online; 0.2% / 0.3% card present |
| Commercial card · three-party schemecorporate cards, AMEX | outside the capswhatever the country |
EEA = the European Union + Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway. The caps outside the EEA do not come from the IFR but from commitments Visa and Mastercard gave the European Commission in 2019, extended to 2029: that is the 1.5% in the Brexit case above.